Louisiana State University Political Science Report Supreme Court Argumentative Essay

Report #5: Supreme Court

After watching the video “U.S. Supreme Court Justices Antonin Scalia & Stephen Breyer: Conversation on the Constitution (2009)” (link provided below), write a brief report. The report should contain three separate sections that address all the points in each set of questions. Notice the expected word count for each section (exceeding the word count will not negatively affect your grade, but please try to stay within the range).

1. Describe the competing perspectives used by Supreme Courts Justices in interpreting the U.S. Constitution. In your answer be certain to elaborate on what is meant by “originalism” and alternatives to this perspective. (approximately 100-150 words)

2. Describe the views of Constitutional interpretation held by each of the two Justices in the video. How do they describe their philosophy and what do they say guides their decision making? (approximately 150-200 words)

3. List and describe one point each made by Justice Breyer and Justice Scalia that you found particularly interesting, novel, or insightful. (approximately 150-200 words)

Be careful not to plagiarize. If you want to quote directly from the text or from the video, do so using quotation marks (giving the page number if you quote the text). But try to do this sparingly and simply use your own words in addressing the questions.

In your writing, use an analytical tone that is free of your personal opinions. In other words, try to answer the questions in a straightforward and objective manner.

Link to video: